You took a flat on rent five years ago. It was bare and tired, so you spent your own money making it liveable — a modular kitchen, fitted wardrobes, an overhead water tank, ceiling fans, a small wall you built to split one big room into two. It became a home. Now the lease is ending. Your landlord says everything you fixed to the property stays with him and you walk out with nothing. You feel cheated. Can you pull out the wardrobes and the kitchen you paid for? Do you get any money back? And on top of that, the landlord is now demanding you "restore" the flat to how it was — so are you supposed to pay to undo your own work?
This is one of the quietest but most bitter rental disputes in India. Money has been spent, the relationship is ending, and nobody is sure who owns what. The law actually has clear rules, and they come mostly from two parts of one section of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
The Starting Point: What the Law Assumes
The rights and duties between a landlord and tenant are listed in Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act. But that section opens with five very important words: it applies "in the absence of a contract or local usage to the contrary". This means the rules below are the default — they apply only where your rental agreement is silent. The moment your lease deed says something specific about renovations, fixtures, or compensation, that written clause takes over. So the first thing anyone in this situation should do is read the agreement.
With that said, the two rules that decide most improvement disputes are: the tenant's right to remove what he attached (Section 108(h)), and the tenant's duty to maintain and restore the property (Section 108(m)). They pull in opposite directions, which is exactly why these fights happen.
Can I Remove the Things I Installed?
Under Section 108(h), a tenant has the right to remove "all things which he has attached to the earth" — and the courts have read this widely. It covers not just loose fittings but trees, machinery, and even a building the tenant raised on the leased land. The tenant is treated as the owner of what he built or fixed. Indian law does not follow the old English idea that whatever is attached to the soil automatically belongs to the owner of the soil. A person who builds on someone else's land with permission is not a trespasser, and the structure does not automatically vest in the landowner.
But this right comes with two firm limits:
- You can only remove while you are still in possession. The law was specifically amended to say the right may be exercised "whilst he is in possession of the property leased and not afterwards". If you hand back the keys and walk out, the right is gone — the fixtures then become the landlord's property. You cannot return later to claim them.
- You must leave the property in the state you received it. The right to remove is paired with a duty to make good. As the courts put it, a tenant who is not a trespasser is entitled to remove the materials, restoring the land to the state in which it was before the improvement was made.
So yes, in principle you can take out the wardrobes, the fans, the kitchen units you fitted — but you must do it before you give up possession, and you must repair the holes and damage that removal causes.
Do I Get Money Back for What I Spent?
This is the hard truth most tenants do not expect. Under the default rule, the tenant's remedy is the right to remove — and the right to remove negatives the right to compensation. In plain words: the law's answer to "I spent money on improvements" is "then take your materials back", not "then the landlord must pay you".
The way it works is that the option lies with the landlord. The landlord can either choose to keep the building or fixture by paying the tenant compensation for its value, or, if he does not want to pay, he must allow the tenant to remove it. The choice is his, not yours. And there is a sharp corollary: if there is nothing that can be removed — the classic example in the case law is a tenant who dug a well in the property — there is no right to compensation at all. You cannot carry a well away, and the law will not make the landlord pay for it.
This is why the lease deed matters so much. Many well-drafted agreements contain a special clause on the tenant's right of removal and compensation. Where such a clause exists, it governs, and the default "remove-or-nothing" rule steps aside. The Supreme Court has upheld arrangements where a tenant agreed in the contract to hand over a building to the landlord at the end of the lease without any right to compensation — because the parties had agreed to it. Whatever your agreement says on this point is likely to be the final word.
What If I Built a Wall or a Permanent Structure?
Removing a wardrobe is one thing. Building a permanent structure is another, and here the tenant can actually be in the wrong. Even where the agreement says nothing, Section 108(p) stops a tenant from erecting any permanent structure on the property without the landlord's consent (farming structures aside). A tenant who puts up unauthorised permanent construction is liable to be evicted for it.
Whether something counts as "permanent" is a question of fact. Courts look at the nature of the structure, the materials used, how firmly it is annexed, how long it is meant to last, and whether it can be removed without substantially damaging the premises. The good news for tenants: courts have held that a tenant is entitled to make alterations and adjustments to suit his needs, and the landlord cannot object, so long as no material alteration or lasting damage results that the tenant cannot himself restore at his own cost when he vacates. A collapsible gate at the entrance, a light partition wall of mud or brick that can be taken down easily, replacing a worn tin roof — these have been held not to be permanent structures. But demolishing old rooms and building new ones without consent has been held a serious enough breach to justify eviction.
One more point worth knowing: the landlord's consent for a structure does not always have to be taken before you build. The law speaks of building "without consent", not "without prior consent", so consent can come afterwards — but if a dispute arises, it is the landlord who must establish that consent was never given.
The Other Side: My Duty to Maintain and Hand Back the Property
Improvements are only half the story. Section 108(m) places two real duties on every tenant, and ignoring them is what turns a deposit dispute into a court case. The section creates two implied promises:
- To keep the property in repair — you must maintain it in as good a condition as you found it, throughout the whole period of the tenancy. A landlord can sue on this duty from time to time during the lease.
- To restore it in repair — at the end, you must yield up the property in as good a condition as you found it. A landlord can sue on this duty only at the end of the term.
Two exceptions soften this. You are not liable for damage caused by reasonable wear and tear — the ordinary ageing that comes from normal use, exposure, and the passage of time. And you are not liable for damage from irresistible force — storm, flood, accidental fire not caused by your negligence. But the line is fine: wear and tear excuses you only for damage directly caused by ordinary use; you still have to stop a small problem from growing into a big one. And you remain liable for fire caused by your own negligence, and even for material damage caused by a sub-tenant you put in.
There is also a procedural protection for tenants. Where damage is caused by the tenant's act or default, the tenant is bound to make it good within three months from the date of a written notice from the landlord. If the landlord gives no such notice, the tenant cannot be said to have breached this duty. So a landlord who simply forfeits the deposit without ever giving written notice of the specific damage is on weak ground.
Restoration vs Removal: Where Tenants Get Trapped
Here is the trap that catches careful, well-meaning tenants. You have a right to remove your fixtures (Section 108(h)) and a duty to restore the property to its original condition (Section 108(m)). These two combine into one practical reality: if you remove what you installed, you must repair the damage the removal causes — before you give up possession.
Many tenants think they can simply rip out the wardrobes on the last day, drop the keys, and leave. But pulling fittings out of walls leaves holes, exposed wiring, damaged plaster, gaps in flooring. If you hand back the flat in that state, you have removed lawfully but failed to restore — and the landlord can claim the cost of putting the premises back into the condition required by Section 108(m). The measure of damages for failing to restore is, broadly, the cost of bringing the premises up to the required state of repair. Any unauthorised alteration is treated as much a breach as plain dilapidation.
The smart approach is to plan the exit: decide well in advance what you will remove and what you will leave, do the removal and the making-good while you are still in possession, and document the final handover condition. If you cannot or do not want to restore, it is often better to leave the fixtures behind and negotiate — remembering that whether the landlord pays you anything for them is, under the default rule, his choice.
Does Rent Control or Local Law Change Anything?
It can. The Transfer of Property Act rules are the general law, but several States have rent control statutes and special tenancy laws that modify them. The source material notes, for example, that certain State laws on tenants' protection repeal or modify the TP Act to the extent needed to give effect to their own provisions — including on the question of compensation for a superstructure built by the tenant. Some State rent Acts also place their own duties on the landlord, such as keeping the premises windproof and waterproof and doing periodical repairs, and give the tenant a route to do urgent repairs and adjust the cost against rent.
The practical takeaway is this: do not assume the bare TP Act rule is the last word in your city. Whether a rent control law applies, and what it says about improvements and repairs, can change both the answer and which forum you go to. This is the part of an improvements dispute where local legal advice genuinely earns its fee.
What Should I Actually Do Now?
Whether you are the tenant who spent the money or the owner being asked to pay, these steps will protect your position.
- Read the lease deed first. Look for any clause on renovations, alterations, fixtures, removal rights, compensation, and "restore to original condition". A specific clause overrides every default rule discussed here.
- Make a list of every improvement. Separate them into three buckets: things that can be removed (fans, wardrobes, units), things fixed into the structure, and things that simply cannot be taken away (a well, sunk pipework, a built wall).
- Act while you are still in possession. The tenant's right to remove fixtures ends the moment possession is given up. Do not hand over the keys and then expect to come back for anything.
- If you remove, also restore. Repair the holes, plaster, wiring and flooring that removal damages, before handover. Removing lawfully but leaving damage still makes you liable.
- Insist on written notice for damage claims. A landlord claiming damage must give written notice; the tenant then has three months to make it good. Do not pay a vague verbal demand.
- Photograph and document. Record the condition at handover. If there is a dispute later, this is your evidence on both the restoration duty and the wear-and-tear defence.
- Do a joint inspection. Walk through the property together at the end, ideally with a simple signed condition note. This single step prevents most deposit and restoration fights.
- Get a proper handover and settlement in writing. If the landlord agrees to keep certain fixtures, or to pay for them, or to waive restoration, put it on paper. A clear written record or legal notice avoids "you never said that" later.
- Check your city's rent control law. It can change the rules on compensation, repairs, and which court hears the dispute.
- Take advice before you act, not after. Whether to remove, restore, leave behind, or negotiate is a decision that turns on your exact agreement. A short consultation early is far cheaper than fixing a wrong move.
Settling It Before It Becomes a Court Case
Improvement disputes feel unfair to everyone in them. The tenant feels robbed of money honestly spent. The owner feels asked to pay for changes he never wanted. Both are partly right, and that is exactly why these matters drag on — until someone reads the agreement and applies the actual rule. The law is not vague here. The tenant generally has a right to remove, not an automatic right to be paid; the landlord usually holds the option of keeping-and-paying or letting-the-tenant-remove; and the tenant carries a real duty to hand the property back in good order.
If you are facing this at the end of a tenancy and the deposit, the fixtures and the restoration cost are all in dispute, the property law team at Pinaka Legal can read your lease deed, tell you plainly who owns what and who owes what, and help you reach a clean settlement — or, if it comes to it, send the right notice and pursue the right claim. Knowing your true position before the handover is what keeps this out of court.
Written by the Pinaka Legal Editorial Team. For queries, call +91 8595704798 or email info@pinakalegal.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who keeps the fixtures I installed in a rented house?
It depends on timing and on your agreement. Under Section 108(h) of the Transfer of Property Act, a tenant is treated as the owner of what he attached and has the right to remove it — but only while still in possession. If you hand back the keys without removing your fixtures, they become the landlord's property. And if your lease deed has a specific clause on fixtures, that clause decides the question instead of this default rule.
Can a tenant remove fixtures after the lease ends?
Only while still in possession of the property. The law was specifically amended to say the right to remove can be exercised 'whilst he is in possession of the property leased and not afterwards'. Once you give up possession, the right is gone and the fixtures pass to the landlord. So the practical rule is: remove before you hand over the keys, never after.
I spent a lot of money renovating — will my landlord pay me back?
Usually not automatically. Under the default rule, the tenant's remedy is the right to remove the materials, and that right negatives the right to compensation. The option lies with the landlord: he can choose to keep the improvement by paying you for it, or refuse to pay and let you remove it. If something cannot be removed at all, such as a well, there is no right to compensation. A clause in your lease deed can change all of this.
Do I have to restore the rented property to its original condition?
Yes, as a general rule. Section 108(m) of the Transfer of Property Act requires a tenant to keep the property in repair during the tenancy and to yield it up at the end in as good a condition as it was received, subject only to reasonable wear and tear and irresistible force. If you remove fixtures you installed, you must also repair the damage the removal causes before handing back possession.
What is 'reasonable wear and tear' and am I liable for it?
No, you are not liable for reasonable wear and tear. It means the ordinary deterioration caused by normal use, exposure to air, and the passage of time — things like faded paint or worn flooring from everyday living. But the exception is narrow: it only covers damage directly caused by ordinary use, and you are still expected to prevent a small wear-and-tear problem from growing into larger damage.
Can I build a wall or permanent structure in my rented home?
Not without the landlord's consent. Section 108(p) bars a tenant from erecting a permanent structure without consent, and doing so can be a ground for eviction. However, courts allow tenants to make alterations and adjustments to suit their needs as long as no material alteration or lasting damage results that cannot be restored at the tenant's own cost. Whether something is 'permanent' depends on its nature, materials, and how it is annexed.
My landlord is keeping my deposit for damage. Can he do that without telling me?
He is on weak ground if he gave no written notice. Section 108(m) provides that where damage is caused by the tenant's act or default, the tenant must make it good within three months of a written notice from the landlord. If no such notice was given, the tenant cannot be said to have breached the duty. Do not pay a vague verbal demand — ask for the claim and the notice in writing.
Who pays for repairs during the tenancy — landlord or tenant?
Under the default rule in Section 108(m), the tenant must keep the property in as good a condition as he found it during the whole term, subject to wear and tear and irresistible force. But this is subject to your agreement and to any rent control law in your State, some of which place repair duties on the landlord, such as keeping the premises windproof and waterproof. Always check the lease deed and the local law together.
If I remove my wardrobes and fittings, who fixes the holes left behind?
You do. The tenant's right to remove fixtures is paired with the duty to restore the land to the state it was in before the improvement was made. Removing your fittings lawfully but leaving holes, damaged plaster or exposed wiring means you have failed to restore, and the landlord can claim the cost of putting the premises right. Do the removal and the making-good together, before handover.
Does the lease agreement override these legal rules on improvements?
Yes. Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act applies only 'in the absence of a contract or local usage to the contrary'. If your lease deed has a specific clause on renovations, fixtures, removal, compensation or restoration, that clause governs. The Supreme Court has upheld agreements where a tenant agreed to hand over a building at the end of the lease without any compensation, simply because the parties had contracted for it.
Am I responsible if my sub-tenant damaged the property?
Yes. The source law makes the tenant responsible for material damage caused to the premises by a sub-tenant, because the landlord has no direct legal relationship with the sub-tenant. As the original tenant, your duty under Section 108(m) to maintain and restore the property continues, and damage done by someone you put into the premises is treated as your responsibility towards the landlord.
Can the landlord enter to inspect the condition of the property?
Yes, but at reasonable times. Section 108(m) gives the landlord statutory authority to enter the premises to inspect their state of repair. Without that authority or an express power in the lease, an entry could be treated as trespass. The condition that entry be at 'reasonable times' is generally satisfied if the landlord gives notice of his visit, and you should not obstruct a reasonable inspection.
For more articles on Indian law, visit the Pinaka Legal Blog.